The Unseen Disconnect: Why Some CEOs Overlook Employees and HR

Ford Motor Company, a titan in the automobile industry, faced severe challenges in the early 2000s. The company was battling financial losses, a declining market share, and an entrenched, siloed corporate culture. Enter Alan Mulally in 2006. Mulally’s leadership at Ford provides a compelling study on the importance of focusing on employees and organizational culture to turn around a giant corporation’s fortunes.

One of Mulally’s first steps as CEO was to communicate a clear vision for Ford: a focus on a unified brand around the globe. He coined the term “One Ford,” emphasizing unity and alignment. By setting a clear direction, employees knew what they were working towards.

Mulally recognized that Ford’s culture was compartmentalized, with different departments working in isolation, sometimes even in competition. He introduced weekly management meetings where leaders from all sectors came together to discuss challenges, share data, and collaborate on solutions. This transparency was a departure from the past and fostered an environment of mutual trust and cooperation.

To shift the corporate culture, Mulally created an atmosphere where mistakes were seen as learning opportunities rather than failures to be penalized. In one famous instance, when a manager openly admitted a mistake during a meeting, instead of reprimanding him, Mulally applauded. This act signaled a cultural shift toward openness, accountability, and continuous improvement.

Mulally frequently interacted with employees on the factory floor and in corporate offices. He listened to their concerns, celebrated their achievements, and emphasized the importance of their roles in Ford’s turnaround. This approach bolstered employee morale and made them feel valued.

Under Mulally’s leadership, Ford witnessed a remarkable turnaround. The company managed to avoid the bankruptcy filings that its U.S. counterparts, General Motors, and Chrysler, had to undergo in 2008. By 2010, Ford reported one of the highest annual profits in its history. Beyond the financial success, the company underwent a profound cultural transformation, becoming more collaborative, transparent, and forward-looking.

Mulally’s tenure at Ford underscores the immense impact a CEO can have when they prioritize employees, culture, and collaboration. It reiterates the belief that the heart of a company lies in its people and the culture that binds them together.

In today’s dynamic corporate environment, the strength of an organization’s human capital is more crucial than ever. Yet, a perplexing question arises: Why do some CEOs seem to sideline employees and human resources? Drawing from extensive data and organizational analytics, we delve into this apparent disconnect.

Misaligned Metrics of Success:

The primary metrics that CEOs often grapple with revolve around profitability, market share, and shareholder value. And while these are fundamental to business sustainability, they can overshadow the more intangible – yet equally crucial – metrics related to employee engagement, well-being, and satisfaction. When success is defined solely by numbers on a balance sheet, the human elements can be inadvertently left behind.

Historically, businesses have emphasized tangible assets—physical infrastructure, products, or intellectual property. The 21st-century shift toward the knowledge economy requires valuing intangibles like talent, innovation, and culture. CEOs, especially those from traditional sectors, might face challenges navigating this paradigm shift.

Immediate financial pressures, quarterly earnings reports, and shareholder demands can divert a CEO’s attention from longer-term investments in human capital. While talent development, workplace culture, and employee well-being drive long-term growth, they don’t always yield immediate, tangible results, causing them to be sidelined.

In the world of business, data drives decisions. While financial metrics are clear and well-established, many CEOs may not have clear visibility into metrics related to employee engagement or the ROI of a robust HR strategy. Without this data-driven insight, it becomes challenging to prioritize these areas.

The Misconception of HR as a Support Role:

There’s a lingering perception in some business circles that HR exists merely to manage recruitment, handle disputes, and oversee payroll. The transformative power of HR as a strategic partner, driving culture, engagement, and ultimately performance, might be overlooked.

While challenges exist, they’re not insurmountable. Here are pathways for CEOs to integrate a more people-centric approach:

  • Integrate Employee Metrics: CEOs should work closely with HR to establish clear, actionable metrics around employee engagement, satisfaction, and retention, ensuring these metrics are regularly reviewed alongside financial ones.

  • Prioritize Engagement: Engaged employees are more productive, innovative, and loyal. By prioritizing engagement, CEOs can drive better workplace culture and better bottom-line results.

  • See HR as a Strategic Partner: By valuing HR not just as a support function but as a critical strategic partner, CEOs can leverage the transformative power of human capital for organizational success.

The corporate world is undergoing a seismic shift. As we navigate the complexities of the modern business landscape, it’s essential to recognize that an organization’s most valuable asset isn’t its products or services – but its people. CEOs can unlock unparalleled growth and success by bridging the disconnect and placing employees and HR at the heart of strategic decisions.

The Transformation of IBM under Louis V. Gerstner Jr.

In the early 1990s, International Business Machines (IBM) was on the brink of collapse. Once a dominant player in the technology industry, the company was losing billions and was in danger of being split apart. In 1993, Louis V. Gerstner Jr. took the reins as IBM’s CEO. What makes Gerstner’s tenure particularly interesting in the context of our discussion is not just the financial turnaround he spearheaded but also the shift in company culture and his focus on the human capital of IBM.

While IBM had significant financial and operational issues, Gerstner identified another crucial problem: the company’s inward-focused culture. Employees were siloed, innovation was stagnant, and complacency was damaging the company from the inside.

Gerstner believed that the company’s greatest asset was its people. He initiated town hall meetings, openly discussing the company’s challenges and seeking feedback from employees at all levels. By doing so, he gained insights and started rebuilding trust within the organization.

HR as a Strategic Weapon:

Instead of massive layoffs, which many expected given IBM’s financial state, Gerstner sought ways to retrain and redeploy talent within the company. While there were inevitably some layoffs, the emphasis was on leveraging the existing talent pool and aligning it with the company’s new direction.

Gerstner introduced a customer-focused approach, breaking down internal silos and fostering collaboration across different units. He championed that IBM’s employees should think less about individual units and more about the entire enterprise and its customers.

Outcome:

Under Gerstner’s leadership, IBM transformed from a hardware company on the brink of bankruptcy to a services and software giant, with its stock price rising dramatically during his tenure. But more importantly, the company underwent a cultural revolution, with employees at the heart of its transformation.

This example serves as a testament to the power of placing employees and human resources at the forefront of strategic decision-making. When a CEO understands and harnesses the potential of the organization’s human capital, even a behemoth on the edge of collapse can be steered back to prominence.

Today’s workforce, marked by Millennials and Gen Z, has different aspirations and values than previous generations. They seek purpose, flexibility, personal growth, and well-being. These evolving expectations might seem elusive for CEOs accustomed to traditional workplace norms. To harness the potential of these generations, CEOs need to invest time to actively understand and align with their values.

Digitalization has not only revolutionized business operations but also employee expectations. The digital era has redefined the workplace from flexible remote work to digital training platforms. CEOs must recognize that modern HR isn’t just about personnel management; it’s about crafting a digital-first employee experience that attracts, retains, and nurtures top talent.

Re-imagining Leadership Dynamics:

Leadership today is less about authority and more about influence, collaboration, and empowerment. CEOs should transition from directive leaders to coaches, guiding their teams, fostering innovation, and building resilience. This mindset shift can help cultivate a leadership style that places employees at the core of the business strategy.

Strategies for a People-Centric Transformation:

  • Continuous Learning and Adaptability: CEOs should adopt a lifelong learning approach, keeping themselves updated with the latest trends in people management, organizational behavior, and the global talent landscape.

  • Feedback Loops: Building regular feedback mechanisms where employees can voice their opinions, concerns, and suggestions can offer invaluable insights to CEOs. It enhances employee engagement and provides actionable intelligence for organizational betterment.

  • Collaborate with Thought Leaders: By connecting with thought leaders, attending HR-focused seminars, or engaging with employee engagement consultancies, CEOs can gain fresh perspectives on people management and integrate best practices into their strategy.

To encapsulate, as the business ecosystem becomes more volatile, complex, and ambiguous, the role of human capital in ensuring sustainability and growth becomes paramount. As the torchbearers of organizational vision, CEOs must embrace a more holistic, employee-centric approach. By placing human resources and employees at the epicenter of decision-making, they can enhance organizational culture and fortify the foundation for long-term success.

About Jim Woods
Jim Woods is the President & CEO of Woods Kovalova Group, a diversity, equity & inclusion expert who helping organizations for over 20 years. He knows how to create an environment where everyone feels respected and valued – no matter who they are or their background. His work with Fortune 500 companies such as Cisco Systems, Microsoft, and Boeing demonstrates that he understands how major companies operate.

With this level of expertise, you can be confident that Jim will help your organization reach its goals of creating a safe and equitable workplace. In addition, his strategies have proven successful in inspiring corporate cultures worldwide to pursue true transformation toward anti-racism and social change within their ranks.

Reach out today to learn how partnerships with Jim’s team at Woods Kovalova Group can make meaningful changes in your organization’s culture!