Pitfalls of Command and Control Idea of Performance Management
Now more than ever, businesses must deal with the challenge of coordinating the activities of their remote workforces across different identity systems. Consolidating performance management strategies into the standard command-and-control approach is inefficient despite the many complexities of such leadership. Leaders would have more faith and trust in the output of their remote employees if command-and-control strategies worked for performance management. Managers can waste time on challenging initiatives that don't lead to growth or boost team morale because they can't track results accurately or provide meaningful feedback fast enough. More integrated and adaptive methods should be cultivated to guarantee smooth operations with clarity and optimal completion rates rather than relying solely on a rigid system that can impede progress and even limit innovation.
An introduction to the command-and-control idea of performance management
While the concept of performance management based on top-down directives is not new, debates persist over whether or not it is effective. This method, which promotes a hierarchical style of decision-making in which superiors set policy and employees carry it out, regrettably continues. This way of thinking was developed to guarantee that assignments would be carried out without a hitch, thanks to a well-defined chain of command. First, however, we must consider the model's flexibility and ability to inspire the innovation, collaboration, and originality that modern businesses desperately need in light of the rapid changes in the business world. Because of this, more and more top-level managers and executives are adopting the view that a leadership style that encourages and rewards collaborative decision-making is the most effective strategy for fostering an environment where organizations can thrive over the long term.
Why this approach may not be beneficial
To innovate and advance, one must be willing to take risks and overcome obstacles. It's accessible to rely solely on tried-and-true methods whenever a problem arises, but this can limit our effectiveness in certain situations. We can learn a lot by realizing that being open to change and considering things from different angles allows us to develop more well-rounded solutions. Although taking the safe route may seem like the better option, it often leads to complacency and the loss of valuable opportunities. Kanter emphasizes the importance of remaining flexible in the face of change, trying new approaches, and working with experts from different fields to promote innovation and progress. So the next time we have to make a choice, let's try to leave the safety of what's known behind in favor of the riskier territory of what's unknown, thereby realizing our ideas' and projects' full potential.
How command-and-control management can lead to disengagement and frustration
Management styles from the past, such as command and control, can backfire in today's fast-paced business environment, where employees are more likely to feel disengaged and frustrated. Workers may feel disempowered, and creative expression may be stifled when managers make decisions and assign tasks without consulting them. In addition, teams rarely reach their full potential when led from the top down because of the low levels of communication and collaboration. Workers who don't believe they are valued and appreciated often disengage from their work and produce subpar results. Organizations lose their ability to compete in today's ever-changing business environment because of this inability to change. Leaders can avoid the pitfalls of command-and-control management by adopting a more inclusive, empowering approach that places a premium on the contributions of all employees, promotes open lines of communication, and encourages collaboration between departments and departments within an organization. Sustainable growth and success can be fostered by adopting a management style that is open to change and can adapt to the needs of its employees.
Advantages of using a more collaborative approach to performance management
The necessity for a more collaborative style of performance management has never been more apparent than it is today with increased remote work. With this approach, leaders can trust that their teams can be productive and continue to measure performance objectively via tangible work results, such as meeting goals and deadlines. By involving everyone in the organization in setting goals and establishing expectations, leaders create a culture of accountability where everyone works together for a common purpose and as a part of the same team. A collaborative approach encourages employees to take ownership of their outcomes and allows them to develop new skills. This approach fosters a greater sense of employee engagement, which helps create an environment of improved efficiency and productivity.
Examples of how different organizations have used collaboration to build performance
Collaboration within organizations is an effective method of raising output. For example, the UN Environment Programme and the World Health Organization launched the Health and Environment Linkages Initiative (HELI) to promote global health and environmental sustainability policies synergies. As a result of this cooperative effort, we can better combat threats to public health without compromising environmental standards. Apple and IBM's partnership is a notable example of a company working together. In 2014, former competitors joined forces to create cloud-based platforms and specialized applications, simplifying business services and leading to innovations like IBM Watson Health. Teach for America has built a vast network of educators, schools, and local institutions through its partnerships with local school districts, improving education quality and fostering community growth in the nonprofit sector. Collaboration plays a pivotal role in allowing these organizations to boost performance, develop novel solutions, and have far-reaching effects on society, as evidenced by the success of these partnerships.
Tips for leaders on how they can use collaboration in their organizations
Organizations that actively promote a culture of collaboration are better equipped to adapt to the dynamic nature of today's workplace. If you want to foster growth and innovation in your organization, one of the most important things you can do as a leader is to promote a culture that encourages teamwork. Setting a common goal that unites the team and focuses on collective efforts is the first step in introducing collaboration into your organization. It's vital to foster an environment where people feel comfortable talking to one another and sharing their ideas, as this cultivates an atmosphere where innovative solutions to problems and careful deliberation over options can flourish. Positive results and team achievements should be highlighted and celebrated to increase trust and a sense of belonging among team members. It's also important to remember that collaboration is a living thing that needs constant nurturing and adjustment to thrive in your workplace. If you want to have a lasting effect on the long-term success of your company, you need to cultivate and harness the power of collaboration.
In conclusion, the conventional "command and control" method of managing performance may not be the best. This method often results in disinterest and anger among remote staff. However, a performance management strategy emphasizing teamwork and empathy can boost productivity and morale. Successful performance improvement initiatives have been implemented at many companies, including Boeing, Microsoft, and Apple, all of which have embraced collaboration. Leaders can use several specific pointers to incorporate teamwork into their performance management strategies. First, success in the workplace is guaranteed by adopting an organization's ongoing collaboration among its employees and leaders. With this frame of mind, businesses can create high-performing workplaces that value their employees and encourage them to give their all.
Image courtesy of Unsplash
About Jim Woods
Jim Woods is a diversity, equity and inclusion expert with over 20 years of experience in the field. He has worked with organizations of all sizes, from small non-profits to large Fortune 500 companies, helping them to create more inclusive and equitable workplaces. Learn about our team.
Jim is passionate about promoting diversity and inclusion in the workplace and has a track record of success in implementing effective DEI strategies. He deeply understands the challenges and opportunities that organizations face when building a more diverse and inclusive culture and is skilled at working with leadership teams to develop and execute strategies that drive positive change.
In addition to his work as a DEI expert, Jim is also a sought-after speaker and trainer. He has spoken at conferences and events worldwide, sharing his knowledge and insights on unconscious bias, cultural competency, and inclusive leadership. He also frequently contributes to industry publications, sharing his expertise and thought leadership on DEI best practices.
Jim holds a bachelor's degree in business administration and a master's in organizational development and human resources.
Jim is a highly respected and accomplished DEI expert with a proven track record of helping organizations build more inclusive and equitable cultures.